« more on Blood Diamond | Main | count your blessings and other ideas for lent »

February 16, 2007

Comments

ash

this is an odd thing to say, even in context. I'm tempted to say 'well of course you should care about who your doctor is!' I'm not sure why that's bad.

However, I don't want my doctor to keep me alive forever. I just want to know he or she is vaguely competant.

Arguably, it does not matter who the preist is. God functions through them, however worthy they are or are not. The 26th Article of Religion for the CofE (i do not think they apply across the communion) tells us that provided the minister ministers not in his name, but Christ's, their 'unworthiness... hinders not' the sacraments.

andy goodliff

This is a typical Hauerwas kind of statement. I think there is just a little bit of rhetoric going on here. The bit that explains why he talks about who's more important your doctor or your priest is the last sentence that as Christians we live lives that act if God doesn't matter. If God doesn't matter a doctor becomes the most important person in your life because he is the one who keeps you alive.

fernando

I agree that it is a typically Hauerwasian statement - intially captivating, but the more you think about it, the less compeling it becomes.

If one claims that the consequences of a bad diagnosis are greater than the consequences of a bad sermon, how does that "prove" a lack of faith. If the Godly path is illness or premature death, why did Jesus heal or raise people? Why bother praying for doctors to do their job well?

The comments to this entry are closed.

My Photo

My Library

Pages

Blog powered by Typepad